https://www.newindianexpress.com/nation/2022/aug/20/like-ias-ips-railways-to-allow-juniors-peers-to-evaluate-officials-for-promotion-2489578.html
On 22 Jun 2022 had taken up case with authorities for change in selection process & writing of ACR for AF & civilian.Those who are in my email list can see full case
This is taking shape
....
OFFICERS SELECTION PROCESS & FOR PROMOTION REQUIRES A CHANGE IN ORDER TO
GET BEST OFFICER AT EVERY STEP ON LADDER OF PROMOTION& FINALLY FOR TOP SLOT.
1. THREE NATIONS GOT ALMOST SAME SLOT TO RISE, JAPAN WAS RUINED IN 1945
INDIA GOT FREEDOM IN 1947
CHINA IN 1949.
OTHER TWO NATIONS ARE
QUITE POWERFUL & WE ARE STILL STRUGGLING, THE ROOT CAUSE IS BURECRACY
BAD GOVERNACE, PUBLIC SERVANTS HAVE BECOME MASTERS LIKE BRITISHER ,
JUST WITH ONE GRADUATION QUALIFICATION THEY CAN HEAD ANY MINISTRY THUS
JACK OF ALL TRADES MASTER OF NONE.
2. ALL GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES INCLUDING ARMED FORCES & RAILWAY SHOULD BE
Assessed WITH SINGLE YARD STICK
A] PERFORMANCE SPECIAL TO CORP/ ORGANISATION [SHOULD CARRY WEIGHTAGE
OF 30%. TARGETS SHOULD BE SET AS PER CORPORATE AKIN TO ON THE JOB]
B] PROMOTIONAL TESTS FOR EACH PROMOTION [NO TIME SCALE PROMOTION] KEY
SUBJECTS SHOULD ADMIN+ Finance + DOMESTIC AFFAIRS + INTERNATIONAL
AFFAIRS. THIS SHOULD HAVE 30% WEIGHTAGE
C] LIKE ISRAEL ARMY JUNIOR SHOULD ASSESS THEIR SUPERIORS. THIS SHOULD
CARRY WEIGHTAGE OF 20%
D] NEXT SUPERIOR OFFICER & NEXT SENIOR OFFICER SHOULD HAVE WEIGHTAGE OF 10% EACH
3. ACR QUALITIES SHOULD BE WRITTEN ONLY IN ARITHMETIC NUMBER FORM AND
NOT IN WORD DESCRIPTION AS IT IS HARDLY USED AND IS WITH LOT OF FLAWS.
4. GRADING SHOULD BE IN 5 POINT LIKERT SCALE FOR TEN BEST QUALITIES EXPECTED.
5. GRADING POINT SHOULD BE AS
POOR -1, AVERAGE -2, GOOD -3, EXCELLENT -4
OUTSTANDING -5
SUM OF THEN AWARD POINTS OF ALL QUALITIES AND AVERAGE THEM OUT WILL BE
ACR OF THE INDIVIDUAL BY SUPERIORS, THEN GIVE IT A WEIGHT AGE SAY 30%.
7. CENTRAL GOVT PANEL -10 % FOR HIGHER APPOINTMENTS AND FOR LOWER
APPOINTMENT AS PER DEPARTMENT FUNCTIONING REQUIREMENT
A] MINISTER SAY FM, RM HM EXTRA 3%.
B] PM/CM 3%
C] PRESIDENT /GOVERNOR 4% ON WHOSE PLEASURE FINALLY ONE IS
REQUIRED TO CONTINUE
8. THEN ARRIVE AT AVERAGE % OF ABOVE ACRS
9. HAVE DEEP SELECTION FOR ALL OFFICER PAID BY STATE/CENTRAL GOVT
10.NO PEN PICTURE IS REQUIRED IT IS MORE OF GIMMICK THAN ACR.
11. NO LOOP HOLES NO HIDDEN MARKS SHOULD BE OPEN & CLEAR
12. HAVE COMPUTER BASED SELECTION PROCESS
13. ANY PERSON INVOLVED IN ANY CASE IS NOT TO BE TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT
FOR SELECTION PROCESS FROM ON SET, THUS NO POLITICS & NO COURT CASES.
PRESIDENT /GOVERNOR PLEASURE IS FINALLY REQUIRED FOR CONTINUOUS OF POST.
FINALLY THE ARMY RULE ARMY ACT IPC DEPARTMENT RULES OF CENTER PUBLIC
SECTOR ALSO REQUIRE CHANGE
AS WIFE & CHILDREN ENJOY BENEFIT OF, PAY PENSION & SERVICES,
THUS THERE IS NEED TO BRING THEM UNDER LAW AS HUSBAND
As SPOUSE & children heve taken pie of corruption
PUNISHMENT SCARE WILL ENSURE FEAR FOR DOING CORRUPTION
